Both, Without Apology
For the Christian Witches
Herbs and the old prayers. The moon and the teachings handed down to us. If you’ve quietly held both, you’re not alone, and you’re not doing anything wrong. The Pagan Church of Christ is a community for exactly this. Your gift sustains it.
You don’t have to choose
The old faith and the craft, held together, not as a compromise, but as a fuller picture of the sacred than either alone.
Real community, not a forum
Most Christian witches make do with online groups. We gather in person, in circle, in silence, around a shared meal.
No shame, no fight
A place where the conversation about holding both isn’t a battle. Just people who already live there, glad you found them.
Practicing in private
There is a particular quiet that comes from keeping two halves of your life in separate rooms. The prayers you were raised on, said under your breath in the car. The other practice, herbs drying in a cupboard, a candle lit at the right hour, the moon watched through the kitchen window when the house is finally still. Neither half is hidden because you are ashamed of it. It is hidden because no room you have found will hold both at once without asking you to choose.
The cost of that is rarely dramatic. It is smaller and steadier: the daily editing of yourself, sorting which people get which sentences, the pause before answering a plain question about what you believe. Then the conversation where you are asked to explain how you can possibly hold both, by someone who is not really asking but objecting. You can win that exchange a hundred times and still be exhausted by it.
Online groups carry some of that weight, and they are worth having, especially if there is no one near you. But a forum is not a community. It cannot notice that you have gone quiet for three weeks. It cannot sit beside you in a hard season and say nothing. Reading about a practice is not the same as standing inside one while it happens around you, with no part of it needing explanation.
A room where it is not a debate
The Pagan Church of Christ is young and small, and it has no building of its own. Gatherings happen in rented and borrowed rooms: a weekly Sunday gathering, a circle at each new moon, and a midweek study. The time and place go out by email rather than being posted publicly. That detail matters more to the readers of this page than to most. Plenty of people who hold both halves have sound reasons for not wanting their attendance on public record.
What you would find is not a defense of the way you practice. It is the absence of the argument. Nobody there stages the debate about whether the old faith and the craft can be held together, because it is the ground the whole room is already standing on. You can bring all of yourself through the door and then spend the evening thinking about something else entirely. That is a kind of rest some people have not had in years.
Giving keeps a room rented and a door open. For a church this size, that is most of what steadiness means.
Sustain This Community
Give once, or become a monthly sustainer. The recurring option is selected by default below, and monthly gifts are what truly keep this community alive.
Your gift keeps a rare thing alive: a real, gathered home for people who hold both the old faith and the craft. Give once, or become a monthly sustainer.
The Pagan Church of Christ is a registered 501(c)(3) religious organization (EIN 41-3206994). Your gift is tax-deductible to the fullest extent allowed by law, and is processed securely via Stripe. Read about who we are · Privacy Policy · Contact us